Warning: Work in Progress...
This is a discussion on Sylhet...another independence scene? within the Community Life forums, part of Just Bangali category; Quote: Originally Posted by Masoom I think I repeated my question to many times? May be this person does not consider him/her self as Bangladeshi but Sylheti just like many ...

Advertisement
Want to advertise? Learn how to remove ads

Notices

Tags : debate
Closed Thread
Page 3 of 3:  < 1  2  3  
Thread Tools   Switch to Linear ModeSwitch to Hybrid ModeSwitch to Threaded Mode
ronohungkar's Avatar
ronohungkar
~RokTaKto RoNoKheTro~
Posts/Threads: 1,493/22
Thanks: 697
Thanked 727 Times in 463 Posts
Nominated 0 Times in 0 Posts
TOTW/F/M Award(s): 0
Rep Power/Points: 424/37351
ronohungkar has a reputation beyond reputeronohungkar has a reputation beyond reputeronohungkar has a reputation beyond reputeronohungkar has a reputation beyond reputeronohungkar has a reputation beyond reputeronohungkar has a reputation beyond reputeronohungkar has a reputation beyond reputeronohungkar has a reputation beyond reputeronohungkar has a reputation beyond reputeronohungkar has a reputation beyond reputeronohungkar has a reputation beyond repute
Default Posted February 26th, 2008, 10:52 AM #21 (permalink) |
Quote:
Originally Posted by Masoom
View Post
I think I repeated my question to many times?

May be this person does not consider him/her self as Bangladeshi but Sylheti just like many Bangladeshi, Indian, Pakistani. African etc etc consider themselves British, Americans. Yes you can argue that being British and being Sylheti is not the same but if they were clever to understand this simple fact then would have seen Sylhet as part of Bangladesh. What justification is this to all those Sylheti (majority) who don’t share this ideology? When people from this forum start to curse or use hate words against them? Wouldn’t this just give birth to more hate and separation?


It was not my intention to have anyone curse or swear at anyone. Request to everyone please refrain from cursing or hate words.

And who don't share this ideology? Being one in the community maybe you don't see the attitude of one sylheti to someone who is a non sylheti, but being outside of it....I do see it with open eyes the discrimination. And yes, when I say this....I talk from experience.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Masoom
View Post
Why are we finding faults with Sylheti people, aren’t they part of Bangladesh aren’t they your brothers? What difference is it between you and the poster; both are doing the same job. He is saying,

“WE ARE NOT BANGLADESHI, WE ARE DIFFERENT” and you in reply, “SYLHETI PEOPLE ARE NOT LIKE REST OF US, THEY ARE DIFFERENT, and THEY ARE BAD”. Judge your thread from this point.

Masoom you really wanted to bring it out didn't you. No where in my posts did I ever put you guys down pointing a finger and saying YOU ARE BAD! Now answer of your question....what difference is between me and that poster? I did not assume it, rather to find out I asked an open question on peoples views and what is the truth and what is right. You are turning it over and over to the fact that as if I am lighting a lamp and yelling SYLHETIS ARE MOFO'S. Did I do that? Then why are you repeating it over and over?

Aren't they my brothers? Did you lose your eye? Where did brotherhood go when people are not taken into jobs because they speak in Bengali and not in the sylheti.

Where did brotherhood go when sylheti people insult and speak out in their own words bad stuffs about a non-sylheti in parties and cultural shows, in their own little little groupings. Even they form a new mosque just because they could not get along with all the others(more like the opposite way around) and they want to have their own mosque.

Judge my thread from it? Masoom, you are sticking to the fact that I opened this thread to invite people to bullshit about Sylheti people and to lower them down while I stated clearly my intention was to talk about this issue and see every one's view. Now if you wanna keep on going with this same offtopic then I have nothing more to say to you.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Masoom
View Post
Ronoh, if I want to find flaws with any district based on a small number of people then it wouldn’t be hard.

Flaws? Yes every one has flaws, among those some does not fall under the word Flaw...they fall under stupidity and irrational behavior.
I live in a world beyond your world....

The Following User Says Thank You to ronohungkar For This Useful Post:
BlackskY (February 26th, 2008)
Masoom's Avatar
Masoom
Experienced Member
Posts/Threads: 545/62
Thanks: 345
Thanked 503 Times in 242 Posts
Nominated 0 Times in 0 Posts
TOTW/F/M Award(s): 0
Rep Power/Points: 279/23999
Masoom has a reputation beyond reputeMasoom has a reputation beyond reputeMasoom has a reputation beyond reputeMasoom has a reputation beyond reputeMasoom has a reputation beyond reputeMasoom has a reputation beyond reputeMasoom has a reputation beyond reputeMasoom has a reputation beyond reputeMasoom has a reputation beyond reputeMasoom has a reputation beyond reputeMasoom has a reputation beyond repute
Default Posted February 26th, 2008, 02:32 PM #22 (permalink) |
Quote:
Originally Posted by ronohungkar
View Post

It was not my intention to have anyone curse or swear at anyone. Request to everyone please refrain from cursing or hate words.

And who don't share this ideology? Being one in the community maybe you don't see the attitude of one sylheti to someone who is a non sylheti, but being outside of it....I do see it with open eyes the discrimination. And yes, when I say this....I talk from experience.





“WE ARE NOT BANGLADESHI, WE ARE DIFFERENT” and you in reply, “SYLHETI PEOPLE ARE NOT LIKE REST OF US, THEY ARE DIFFERENT, and THEY ARE BAD”. Judge your thread from this point.

Masoom you really wanted to bring it out didn't you. No where in my posts did I ever put you guys down pointing a finger and saying YOU ARE BAD! Now answer of your question....what difference is between me and that poster? I did not assume it, rather to find out I asked an open question on peoples views and what is the truth and what is right. You are turning it over and over to the fact that as if I am lighting a lamp and yelling SYLHETIS ARE MOFO'S. Did I do that? Then why are you repeating it over and over?

Aren't they my brothers? Did you lose your eye? Where did brotherhood go when people are not taken into jobs because they speak in Bengali and not in the sylheti.

Where did brotherhood go when sylheti people insult and speak out in their own words bad stuffs about a non-sylheti in parties and cultural shows, in their own little little groupings. Even they form a new mosque just because they could not get along with all the others(more like the opposite way around) and they want to have their own mosque.

Judge my thread from it? Masoom, you are sticking to the fact that I opened this thread to invite people to bullshit about Sylheti people and to lower them down while I stated clearly my intention was to talk about this issue and see every one's view. Now if you wanna keep on going with this same offtopic then I have nothing more to say to you.





Flaws? Yes every one has flaws, among those some does not fall under the word Flaw...they fall under stupidity and irrational behavior.

Ronoh, Just read your own posts.


Quote:
Originally Posted by ronohungkar
View Post
Being one in the community maybe you don't see the attitude of one sylheti to someone who is a non sylheti, but being outside of it....I do see it with open eyes the discrimination. And yes, when I say this....I talk from experience.



Quote:
Originally Posted by ronohungkar
View Post
Masoom you really wanted to bring it out didn't you. No where in my posts did I ever put you guys down pointing a finger and saying YOU ARE BAD! Now answer of your question....what difference is between me and that poster? I did not assume it, rather to find out I asked an open question on peoples views and what is the truth and what is right. You are turning it over and over to the fact that as if I am lighting a lamp and yelling SYLHETIS ARE MOFO'S. Did I do that? Then why are you repeating it over and over?



Quote:
Originally Posted by ronohungkar
View Post
Aren't they my brothers? Did you lose your eye? Where did brotherhood go when people are not taken into jobs because they speak in Bengali and not in the sylheti.


Quote:
Originally Posted by ronohungkar
View Post
Where did brotherhood go when sylheti people insult and speak out in their own words bad stuffs about a non-sylheti in parties and cultural shows, in their own little little groupings. Even they form a new mosque just because they could not get along with all the others(more like the opposite way around) and they want to have their own mosque


Quote:
Originally Posted by ronohungkar
View Post
Judge my thread from it?


Yes I am just doing that and wondering, how could I…

Quote:
Originally Posted by ronohungkar
View Post
Masoom, you are sticking to the fact that I opened this thread to invite people to bullshit about Sylheti people and to lower them down while I stated clearly my intention was to talk about this issue


Trying to know something? I thought you talk from experience.

However I am wondering what percentage of Bangladeshi you represent. Don’t talk for Bangladeshis and just for yourself
I

Quote:
Originally Posted by ronohungkar
View Post
Flaws? Yes every one has flaws, among those some does not fall under the word Flaw...they fall under stupidity and irrational behavior.


I wouldn’t pick any bad peoples or area to prove my countrymen as bad people. You already made the decision that Sylhet should be separated? This really show’s how much at least you love you country!

If someone is advertising a job only for Sylheti speaking then it could been for 2 reasons.
  • Business requirement. Customer’s to be able to communicate easily
  • They don’t want to offer that job to anyone but bring someone from Bangladesh and the requirement of work permit is to first advertise locally, then Europe and only after that internationally you can bring someone to fulfil your requirements. Did you consider this reason before getting offended? Have you ever checked the stats of how many Bangladeshi people from different district are employed by Sylhetis and yes of course employment stats would show more Sylheti working then other district when 8/10 Bangladeshi at least here in the UK are Sylhetis.
Last edited by Masoom; February 26th, 2008 at 03:18 PM. Reason: Doublepost Automerged
The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to Masoom For This Useful Post:
Silent_debator (February 26th, 2008), Soldier (February 26th, 2008)
ronohungkar's Avatar
ronohungkar
~RokTaKto RoNoKheTro~
Posts/Threads: 1,493/22
Thanks: 697
Thanked 727 Times in 463 Posts
Nominated 0 Times in 0 Posts
TOTW/F/M Award(s): 0
Rep Power/Points: 424/37351
ronohungkar has a reputation beyond reputeronohungkar has a reputation beyond reputeronohungkar has a reputation beyond reputeronohungkar has a reputation beyond reputeronohungkar has a reputation beyond reputeronohungkar has a reputation beyond reputeronohungkar has a reputation beyond reputeronohungkar has a reputation beyond reputeronohungkar has a reputation beyond reputeronohungkar has a reputation beyond reputeronohungkar has a reputation beyond repute
Default Posted February 26th, 2008, 07:23 PM #23 (permalink) |
Masoom you are getting funny do you know that?

When I ask for opinions and open talk you have problem with that.

When I represent the things that I saw with my eyes you have problem with that.

When I ask questions based on those you have problem with that.

When I state no kind of vulgar talks yet my opinion you have problem with that.

When I question you with valid points they become invalid and in your words "harassment to Sylheti's"


Maybe for people like you who wants to carry on a discussion according to their own prospective only its better to not discuss at all.


I have seen and heard of these things myself, I came here and asked...is this TRUE? If it is what do you guys think about it? Is it right or wrong. give your views.


Then came you.....stating post over post trying to prove.....I AM CURSING/EXPRESSING HATE for Sylheti people. If I really wanted to do that, I could have come in and posted a note like the one some other member did and call the sylheti's this and that BS. Instead I asked to see what everyone says so that it might be a constructive discussion. For this matter I have nothing more to say to you.
I live in a world beyond your world....

The Following User Says Thank You to ronohungkar For This Useful Post:
BlackskY (February 26th, 2008)
BlackskY's Avatar
BlackskY
ZirO Gr@vitY
Posts/Threads: 656/2
Thanks: 310
Thanked 253 Times in 192 Posts
Nominated 0 Times in 0 Posts
TOTW/F/M Award(s): 0
Rep Power/Points: 166/12751
BlackskY has a reputation beyond reputeBlackskY has a reputation beyond reputeBlackskY has a reputation beyond reputeBlackskY has a reputation beyond reputeBlackskY has a reputation beyond reputeBlackskY has a reputation beyond reputeBlackskY has a reputation beyond reputeBlackskY has a reputation beyond reputeBlackskY has a reputation beyond reputeBlackskY has a reputation beyond reputeBlackskY has a reputation beyond repute
Default Posted February 26th, 2008, 09:48 PM #24 (permalink) |
Quote:
Originally Posted by Silent_debator
View Post
Stop embarrassing us and I say to you not in my name. your comments are pathetic. most terrorist In Bangladesh come from chitagong. Considering this thread syleti people should want independent state.

this's the example of "Silent_debator" ???? i don think ronoH has made any mistake in his posts, he just trying to say some truth about our reality. he wazn't embaressing you guys, why are you taking it personally??. i will tell you what maybe its YOU silent debator (!) who's embarrassing whole chtgong. most terroist in Bangladesh come from chitagong...(!) lol.... everywhere in the world has some good people and some bad. no offence brother, but if some one say "yeah, i agree that most terroist in Bangladesh come from chitagong but if i say almost all RAJAKAR was sylheti (!)" then??? don't just post like that brother. this is not a hard talk section. no one