[ronohungkar]

	Quote:			Originally Posted by ReeV
	Wut Rajakars Did, they wanted their Country all together. Just lyk we wud want if Sylhet wants to be a separate Liberal Country Cuz they have all this other Cultures and Language.

Was browsing through doshomik and came to this. Have heard this same story from several other people too that Sylhet wants to be unique and thinks they should be separate and independent!

Is it true? If it is then...

Now my question is how many of you support this? Justify your thoughts on this. Is it right? Is it wrong? Why or why not they should be separate?




If it's too much of a hard talk for the community life section then Mods please move it to the hard talk section! Thanks!

[Severus]

they can , but then they'll have to pay us heavily for using Chittagong sea port hahaha !

[tamchow]

ami hote pare tara emon dekhai... but persoanlly i dnt think dey want be seperated frm bangladesh... hei eita tik tara nijer city ke ekta alada identity dite chai.. which is not a bad thing.. promote kora to kharap na...

lol severus...

[BlackskY]

	Quote:			Originally Posted by tamchow
	blah.............blah....... hei eita tik tara nijer city ke ekta alada identity dite chai.. which is not a bad thing.. promote kora to kharap na...

im not 100/cent sure, but ye if they do want an perticular "identity", i can say they have already got that identity. ye not that specifically in Bangladesh but in UK they have made an another community (not a Bangeli comunity though). always they say "we're sylheti, not bangladeshi/ bangeli". they always think every bangladeshi are "dhakaya" that is short of redeculas i suppose. sometimes they address themselves as a "Bengali" but commertial/sales/advertising/business purpose only, i have seen in tv several times, we know that, which is no good i guess. bcoz in real life almost all of them are...no need to mention again.

promote is not a bad thing, in fact that is good. all bangeli want that. for example, bogra is even much developed then other divitional city in Bangladesh. why is that ?? bcoz some specific bogra lover unlike some powerful politicians has made that district much developed. we never think about whole country, do we. i don't think so. even i used to think about my native district, where i had spent a long time since my child hood. but you know what, when i started living in london, i can truely realise what my Bangladesh is. its not only dhaka or khulna...i now think about my Bangladesh, and Bangladeshi people. i believe, immigrant Bangladeshi/Bangelis think about whole Bangladesh, xcept our sylheti brothers.

forgetting PAST is not a good thing, don't you think. Thanx.



Desclaimer: we don't hate sylheti people, infact we love them but not their wired speech. we love all Bangladeshi people. This post is not 100/cent completed.

[noble]

bhabai jaina erokom hote pare. porer dhone poddari kore, porgacha hoe beche theke jodi sottikar orthei ebhabe chinta bhabna kore thake tobe taderke to bolte hobe tor -------- (tor mathai sit asey)

[tamchow]

well ami shob chei beshi sylheti manush der shathe chola chol korechi.. hei tik ache ektu dekhatai tar different, hen ten.. but at da end of tara nijeder ke porichito dey as bengaulis (to non sylheti)..
jara shikhito as in pora likha koreche.. tader modhe emon nai... r hei jader modhe ei shikha ta nai tader mentality ta asholi onno rokum...
amar onek porichito ache tara bole je bangladesh shundor not just sylhet, dey like everything abt bangladesh.

but i doubt dey r gonna be like kashmir who want their own country n hen ten...
u cant generalize every da same.. coz its not fair...

r jeikhane kotha utche majhe majhe identity dey as bangalis for commercial basis.. den amra o kemon bangali.. restaurant khuli nijera kintu naam dey indian restaurant??? eita mane?? ki

hei tik ache tara hote pare sylheti bebohar kore karon tader max audience holo sylheti. i mean wats da point in talkin in a diff dialect if their main customers r not goin to understand dem..... tai .. kintu ekhon dekho onek chanel tara tiki shudho bhasha bebohar kore..

ami jani oneke ache je tara diff tara boro, but not shobai, r eita ami tader ke dosh dicchi na karon tader shei shikkha dewa hoi nai.. onke to bangla boltei jane na, to tara kemne bujhbe je bangla ki... oneke to eita o jane je bangladeshe onek city ache not just hobigong, nobigong, mwailbazar, etc etc... dey just dnt knw.. r tader parents rao bole nai.. hei eita parents der dosh... but ki korar...

[Masoom]

Ronoh, I was the first person who used that example and this was solely used only as an example.


Firstly I’ll answer Severus, your understanding about politics seems very limited and before making fun or seriously commenting something like this, do think about your own people and country. If Sylhet was to be an independent state then Bangladesh as a whole will be affected. Bangladesh survives on foreign aid and Sylhet becoming an Independent country would mean sharing that aid and most of that will go to Sylhet.

I said to think about your people is because, this comment might be a joke to many but don’t forget these sort of comments can also be a challenge or create racial hatred between people who are our own but part due to one feeling that we are hated etc and can cause lot of grief to many peoples. I have many friends here from different districts of Bangladesh and having young brothers who very easily get influenced can start discriminating against my own friends (again this is just an example).


Another retaliatory thread and most surprising to me was when Rahul opened a thread against other religion in retaliation of people saying things against Islam. Rahul is the most open minded person in our family and it was very hard to believe this boy can ever let these comments take over his patients.

Now on topic:

I am not saying anything because I am from Sylhet and as stated on the very thread this whole debate started from, “I would never support my country being divided even if it meant one day myself being called Razakar”, but the honest fact is if Sylheti people really wanted independence then it is not very hard for them due to the international support they would get and most importantly India would be the first. Best example of how easy it would be is just to refer the recent Kosovo independence.

Nobel, you as a father I expected to be more mature then what you have just proved. Is this what you will teach your child to curse people based on assumptions! I respect the comment made by Tamchow, there might be people in Sylhet well as everywhere in the world who see them self better then the rest but the greatest grief is when educated, mature people instead of understanding and trying to solve these matters decide to comment negatively and cause more grief. Can you also clarify your comment about, "showing off with other peoples what?"

Many people here are referring to UK Sylheti but have you ever tried to know why that is? In UK 98 % Bangladeshi are from Sylhet and due to this reason most people assume everyone is Sylheti hence so much confusion.

Why do we always pick few bad peoples and assume everyone or most are the same? As I earlier mentioned if Sylheti want Independence then it is not very difficult but why would they when most leaders from Sylhet are high ranked politicians, only when leaders are not happy with the positions is when public are forced to believe every misery is not because of own failures but Government failures to recognise their need and rights. I hope this comment does not create another trash thread thou anyone very interested can have a private debate with me and let’s see how much can you prove that Sylheti people are bad as most of have made them to be.

I hope I didn’t offend anyone and if I did I do apologise and assure you it was unintended.

[basubunan]

Bujhte perchi na eta niye amar montobyo kora thik hobe kina..(Nijeke Marsian bolleo, according to passport ami Indian)
kintu ekta jinis ami bujhi je , keu sokh kore alada hote chay na. Swadhin howata kono sokh allader byapar noy. Odhikarer byapar. Jakhan Odhikare taan pore r seta jakhan besh osohyo rokom haye jay, takhan lok e alada hote chay.
Aj Bharat er North Eastern state gulo je karoner alada hote chay, je karone chardike problem. Ar er janyo somosto dayitto India Government er.
Kono joint family theke jokhon keu alada hote chay, takhan tar somosto day jay Barir kortar opor. Barir kortar management er obhab ei eta hoy. Tai Sylhet jadi alada desh hote chay, tabe tar daay puro puro bortay Bangladesh sorkarer opor. Somosto dayitto Bangali der opor.
Ar ekhane ami kayek joner ja mantobyo dekhlam (khub cheap laglo), setai jadi average bangalir chinta vabna hoy, tabe Sylhet er alada howa uchit. 'Amra chara ora perbe na', 'amra mohan ar ora khub kharap' ei chinta niye cholle je kono community bhenge jay, je kono jati dangar mul e eta. Nazism er suru hoy ekhan thekei.

achha Sylheti ra satyi koto ta bhalo ache Bangladesh e? koto ta developed tara jati hisebe? na ki tara okhane sub-altern? jor kore swakiyota rakhha korar chesta kintu asole sub-alternism er i lokkhon...thik je bahbe bideshe giye bangalira nijeder community toiri kore alada kore..

Bangladesher bangla academy te kotota kaj hoy Sylhetir opor, as an independent language? ami jotodur sunechuilam je ota ke banglar ekta dialect dhore niye kaj hoy okhane...seta ki satyi?

[noble]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Masoom